Fire Engineering Training Community

Where firefighters come to talk training

What size line would you take?
This was a fire I was on one night over ten years ago. It was a great learning fire and the tactics had to be changed for a successful stop.

I can tell you that a great deal went right this night and there were things that happened away from the fire that paid huge dividends.

If you are the first arriving unit and officer, explain where your going and what your doing. I’ll give you a little information to help you along.

-This is in a rural area, no hydrants.

-The house is old. Old newspaper and straw were found in the walls during overhaul.

-We had plenty of manpower.

-On side B there is a door that leads to the kitchen and the stairs go up from the kitchen on that side, just so you know.

I would like to see a great deal of feedback on this one. Please let me know what operations would be going on away from the fire. After I get enough comments, I will post what we did and why it worked.

As always, thanks for your continued support and use this however you want for your training purposes.

Stay safe and be careful out there.

Views: 88

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

First, let thank you all for the comments. There are no right or wrong answers, just great thoughts and ideas for us to all think about and learn from. Now, the rest of the story.


The rest of the story.
There is nothing earth shattering here, but I learned two valuable lessons on this fire.

When we pulled up on this fire, the first arriving engines were all two man cabs. We didn’t have jump seats in any of our trucks at the time. I did some digging and found out that this fire was in 1997.

The drive was narrow and we got hung up in the ditch, blocking the drive right off the bat. Luckily we had multiple trucks rolling at the dispatch and we had adequate personnel.

The first crew stretched a 1 3/4 inch line in through the side B door in the kitchen and advanced up the stairs. The first floor had no smoke or fire at this time. It became apparent fairly quickly that the initial attack was not making any progress.

We advanced a second line, a 2 1/2 inch stretch up the same stairs and made a very fast knock down. The importance of this is that we did this with less than 1000 gallons of water. Why do I stress this?

I have had debates about using large lines when water supplies are limited or late in developing. When asked about using a larger line the response is that they would not use one because they will run out of water too fast. My rebuttal is always that they may just get enough gpm on the fire to put it out before you run out of water. That is exactly what we did. Oh, and two guys handled the hose!

So, lesson 1 is big fire equals big water. If the fire is advanced enough that you will run out of water, it wont make any difference what size your line is. But, the larger line will put out more fire in that short amount of time.

While we were up stairs fighting fire, there was a crew in the living room doing some work. They had started salvage operations in the unaffected part of the house. Understand that we didn’t need extensive ventilation and we had adequate manpower. But, they stacked and covered everything in the living room and did the same in other rooms that were appropriate.

This ended up paying off big with the homeowner. As happy as they were about us putting out their fire, they were just as happy, or even more so, that we protected what had not been damaged by fire but would have been by the water. When they were interviewed by the paper they went on and on about our efforts to protect all of their property.

So, lesson number 2 is to take the time to perform salvage operations if manpower and conditions permit. It is something that is too often overlooked.

By the way, there was no basement here, but all of you are correct in assuming this until you know for sure. All of the responses were great and I really appreciate the time that you took to share.

Stay safe and be careful.
-The rule of thumb that an old timer shared with me about residential fires when I was just beginning is, "If a residential fire has control of more than two rooms, the initial stretch must be a 2 1/2". This advise has always served well and is still applicable today.
-Tom Brennen often said that in a residential fire scenario the 2 1/2 is the most potent and underused weapon we have in our arsenal.
-Though this incident occurred in an area devoid of hydrants the 2 1/2 stretch is still the best option. It does however illustrate rather poignantly, the absolute need for nozzle discipline and the proper and judicious application of available water. The line should be advanced in, the fire located while the Ladder Company opens up to the seat.
-The photo in this scenario depicts a structure that must be properly opened up quickly and manpower must be dedicated to Truck work, which includes the most vital function in a residential fire- performing an early and aggressive primary search. I am recalling the proverb from Chief Mittendorff, "Engines put out fires but Ladders dictate how the fire will be attacked.
-Judging just from the photo it seems that the fastest option is to advance the 2 1/2 inside and up the interior stairs while the Truck opens up the ceiling. As the IC I would not commit firefighters to the roof as it is faster, safer and more efficient in this scenario to pull ceilings and open the walls.
-A 2 1/2 will knock this fire down very quickly. Unfortunately, because of the over reliance on the 1 3/4, many firefighters today have little experience with a 2 1/2. Many times this experience tends to be negative and gained on the drill field in the academy and therein lies the aversion to the use of the 2 1/2.
-The 2 1/2 hand line, when properly operated and pumped, is a seriously powerful resource that can be aggressively employed by an Engine Co. with immediate definitive results.
Awesome points Bric!

I think we have become somewhat lazy these days...I mean that we generally take the smaller lighter line and not the bulky heavier one for attack. The reliance on 1 3/4 is only making us work harder instead of smarter by using a duece and a half when it is needed. Once the fire is knocked down then use the smaller line for extension and mop up.

I also believe that after conducting a search and firefighter safety (venting and RIT), that proprerty conservation is a major goal. I saw a video the other day from the East coast of a fire in an apartment complex where the fire started on the end unit and spread over the roof to the fire wall. It looks like not many big lines were used early to knock it down or used on the 2nd floor apartments to attack the fire from below. They set up a tower and just trounced all the units with water which also affected the first floor and basement units by adding all that weight to the floors.

They could have saved a lot of property damage from my view of the video but it appears they were worried about the roof collapsing in on them. Town & Country Blvd Fire
-Brad, I could not agree with your comments more.
-As to the video, this was an example of very poor, ill-prpepared, reactionary firefighting. And, someone should have shut down the exterior line as the nozzle man was consistently shooting over the top of the house, as is common with this tactic of operating a handline from the ground. Not until the fire burns down to his location is this line effective.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Policy Page

PLEASE NOTE

The login above DOES NOT provide access to Fire Engineering magazine archives. Please go here for our archives.

CONTRIBUTORS NOTE

Our contributors' posts are not vetted by the Fire Engineering technical board, and reflect the views and opinions of the individual authors. Anyone is welcome to participate.

For vetted content, please go to www.fireengineering.com/issues.

We are excited to have you participate in our discussions and interactive forums. Before you begin posting, please take a moment to read our community policy page.  

Be Alert for Spam
We actively monitor the community for spam, however some does slip through. Please use common sense and caution when clicking links. If you suspect you've been hit by spam, e-mail peter.prochilo@clarionevents.com.

FE Podcasts


Check out the most recent episode and schedule of
UPCOMING PODCASTS

Groups

© 2024   Created by fireeng.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service