Fire Engineering Training Community

Where firefighters come to talk training

June 18th, 2007 undoubtedly began like so many other days in our lives, relatively uneventful; each of us following our daily routines, schedule and pace. Shifts were ending while the next ones were starting, roll calls commenced; apparatus and equipment checks were underway, coffee brewing, conversations in the day room, training drills or staff meeting beginning or the start of daily runs being taken in. For Charleston Fire Department Captains Billy Hutchinson, Mike Benke, and Louis Mulkey; Engineers Mark Kelsey and Brad Baity, Assistant Engineer Michael French; and Firefighters Earl Drayton, Melvin Champaign and Brandon Thompson, the day would be anything but routine.

During the evening hours of June 18, 2007, breaking news began to filter through various news outlets of an evolving tragedy in the city of Charleston, S.C. Unconfirmed reports began circulating, indicating a large commercial fire in a Sofa Super Store in Charleston had claimed the lives of several firefighters, although the exact number was still unknown. By the next morning, the smoke had cleared and the tragic facts were evident; that a total of nine firefighters had perished inside the Sofa Super Store. For Captains Billy Hutchinson, Mike Benke, and Louis Mulkey; Engineers Mark Kelsey and Brad Baity, Assistant Engineer Michael French; and Firefighters Earl Drayton, Melvin Champaign and Brandon Thompson, what started off as a routine fire and incident response, ended tragically with their line of duty deaths and a profound affect on so many within the CFD, the Charleston community and within the national fire service in the ensuing months that have passed.

Today marks the one year anniversary of the Sofa Super Store fire. It doesn’t seem like an entire year has passed, with so much happening since that tragic night and the continuing saga of the incident, the department and its operations, training and culture. Take the time today to remember and honor the Charleston 9, for their bravery, courage and duty, for the lives they lead and for the families that they left behind. Reflect on the events of June 18th and the lessons that can be gleaned from the 250-plus-page report that was released on May 15. Take the time to read the report, its recommendations and the lessons learned. Don’t think it can’t happen in your department, community or region.

Take the time to reflect on how you’re operating, your level of training, your attitude and those of your brother and sister firefighters as well as your officers and commanders. What’s the safety culture of your company, your organization or the community? Seek to identify opportunities and apply the lessons learned from the Charleston fire to improve on those situations or conditions that demand change. Remembering; There are NO routine fires, and sometimes, not everyone goes home, all the time.

Check out the resources on the EGH web site and think about next week’s Fire/ EMS Safety, Health and Survival Week and the theme of “ Committed to Long Term Results”. According to the USFA, there were 115 LODD in 2007 and as of the most recent reports, 50 LODD in 2008 thus far. Everyone NEEDS to go home; we all need to do our part to ensure that happens. Stay safe…..

Views: 278


Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Thanks for the links to the report and EGH. It is so important to learn from every LODD in order to prevent future tragedies. Anyone who has ever read a NIOSH LODD report will attest that we see similarities in our own departments and our own members. It is chilling to see the same things go on all around us that led to the deaths of our brothers and sisters in other deparments. As we remember all our fallen brothers and sisters, please make a personal commitment to be a "radical" for safety in your department and your own lifestyle.
Thanks for the imput Chris;
Remember we need to learn from the past, NO MORE HISTORY REPEATING EVENTS [HRE], these NIOSH, LODD and case study reports are our Brother and Sister Firefighters "voices" speaking to us from these report pages. We must champion a new set of safety values in the fire service, and work to enhance our safety culture; we all must do our part, to ensure that everyone does go home.
Stay Safe Brother........

PS. Is Bill Nowicki still on the job in Portland? He was a student of mine in the fire science program back in the mid 1980's. Give him my regards
Yep, Bill is still here! In fact, he just transfered out to the Air Rescue station where I'm working. I will pass on your regards. One last thought about Charleston that I'm not sure gets brought up too often, that is an ISO Class 1 department! What does that say about the ISO rating system? Alot of city managers and fire chiefs will hang their hat on the ISO rating rather than being NFPA compliant. It's time for the fire service to realize that while it's not perfect, NFPA is really our ally when it comes to safety. Stay safe!

Reply to Discussion


Policy Page


The login above DOES NOT provide access to Fire Engineering magazine archives. Please go here for our archives.


Our contributors' posts are not vetted by the Fire Engineering technical board, and reflect the views and opinions of the individual authors. Anyone is welcome to participate.

For vetted content, please go to

We are excited to have you participate in our discussions and interactive forums. Before you begin posting, please take a moment to read our community policy page.  

Be Alert for Spam
We actively monitor the community for spam, however some does slip through. Please use common sense and caution when clicking links. If you suspect you've been hit by spam, e-mail

FE Podcasts

Check out the most recent episode and schedule of

© 2024   Created by fireeng.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service