Fire Engineering Training Community

Where firefighters come to talk training

Another year has come and gone, and we firefighters have paused to remember the brave 343 who gave their lives on that spectacularly horrific morning in Manhattan. We re-live the nightmare by peering at images from that crisp morning, reading gut-wrenching stories from survivor families, and admiring the ceremonies, plaques, and walls of remembrance.


It is right that we do this.


And, even without the t-shirts, helmet stickers and seemingly parroted rote mantras, it isn’t it utterly obvious that we will all “never forget?”


But, are some of us missing something here?


We lost 343 on September 11, 2001. But are you aware that the number lost keeps growing every day to the point where we have lost over another thousand precious lives of first responders who went to work at the World Trade Center immediately following the disaster?


In fact, as of August 2003, an additional 1,140 lives have been lost to cancers linked to their heroic actions in the days and weeks that followed while the fires burned and toxic smoke hovered over everyone. My math brings the running total from the morning of 9/11 through last month to 1,483.


And counting.


From an article in yesterday’s New York Daily News:


“Sadly enough, I am here just two months, and I have identified a dozen new cancer cases, and I have another 25 patients whose diagnostic test results are pending.” -Tina Engel, an oncology nurse at North Shore Hospital’s WTC clinic in Queens


And with all the hype we hear from the conspiracy theorists claiming our government is responsible for the September 11 attacks, nary a peep about the responsibility our federal government has for all the illness and death that followed.


You may remember as I vividly do, within days after the towers fell, former EPA head Christie Whitman declared that the air in Manhattan is "safe to breathe" and the water is "safe to drink". As a trained firefighter, I had a feeling this was b*******.


We now know that it was.


You may be surprised to know that first responders were ordered NOT to use protective gear in Manhattan, yet at the Pentagon, anyone NOT wearing full hazmat protective suits were ordered off the crash site.


"The misleading communications by civic leaders and their failure to insist on respiratory protection in the days, weeks and months after the initial rescue operation ended undoubtedly contributed and will continue to contribute to sickness in the rescue and recovery workers and in the citizens of Lower Manhattan," -Dr Philip J. Landrigan, chairman of the Department of Community and Preventative Medicine at the Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York. Mount Sinai has screened more than 25,000 Ground Zero responders for illnesses suspected of being related to the dust and treated many of them.

Federal officials also opted not to sound alarms even after tests registered unprecedented levels of dioxin at and around ground zero, documents obtained through freedom of information requests filed by the New York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health (NYCOSH) revealed.


Dioxin, a pollutant that can cause cancer, damage the immune system and lead to developmental problems, is most harmful when absorbed through food. But it can also cause harm when inhaled.


OSHA discussed the alarming test results internally: "Just received a sample taken at the WTC (in or near the plume I believe)," an OSHA employee wrote in an October 2001 email to John Henshaw, the agency's administrator. "The result was very high … EPA is saying it is one of the highest levels they have ever seen." The level was about 1,000 times higher than normal for dioxin.


Despite the anguishing fact that someone should be held liable- both civilly and criminally in my mind- for the illness and deaths of hundreds more, that doesn’t help the thousands who are still suffering for the decisions made that day.


What can be done?


We need to pay more attention to those thousands of first responders who performed admirably and are just now paying the price. They did what they thought was right. The horror that hit us 12 years ago did not end when the Towers came tumbling down, nor did it end every year we toll the bells, read the names, cry the tears.

It keeps on killing us. The attack on America continues to this day.


It is tragic that more of us Americans, more of us Brothers and Sisters, aren’t screaming loudly in support for these forgotten victims at the very time we mourn our dead from that day.

We owe it to them- indeed we owe it to ourselves as Americans- to move beyond the number 343 and realize the price that continues to be paid by hundreds, perhaps thousands in years to come, of our Brothers and Sisters years after most of us thinks it is over.


It is right that we do this.

* * * * *

To find out what you can do, please check out:

Firefighter Cancer Foundation

Friends of Firefighters

Firefighter Cancer Support Network

9/11 Day

Views: 244

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion


You have expertly captured within your article the ugliness of a bureaucracy that remained in denial for years about the link between higher rates of cancer in those who rescued on 9/11 and those who continued day in and day out their work at Ground Zero. They wanted us to believe that their cancer was "coincidental".

That 343 of New York's bravest died on 9/11 in the collapses is irrefutable.

That many more continue to die as a result of being there on 9/11 and working Ground Zero for months longer is irrefutable as well. The link to their cancer is obvious. And America should be screaming at the bureaucrats to provide for the brothers and sisters' care.

Let's not forget; cancer isn't killing all of them. Many are suffering in the silence of deep depression, unable to cope without proper care.

Nice work!

Reply to Discussion


Policy Page


The login above DOES NOT provide access to Fire Engineering magazine archives. Please go here for our archives.


Our contributors' posts are not vetted by the Fire Engineering technical board, and reflect the views and opinions of the individual authors. Anyone is welcome to participate.

For vetted content, please go to

We are excited to have you participate in our discussions and interactive forums. Before you begin posting, please take a moment to read our community policy page.  

Be Alert for Spam
We actively monitor the community for spam, however some does slip through. Please use common sense and caution when clicking links. If you suspect you've been hit by spam, e-mail

FE Podcasts

Check out the most recent episode and schedule of

© 2024   Created by fireeng.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service