Fire Engineering Training Community

Where firefighters come to talk training

The trench cut, aka "strip ventilation," is a truck company vertical ventilation tactic that can be utilized to stop the spread of fire across a long, narrow structure, thereby achieving containment of an extending fire by confining the fire to a specific area.

As with any vertical ventilation operation, careful consideration must be given to the safety of the operation. This assessment begins with the determination of the need for vertical ventilation. Once this need has been determined, fire conditons and its impact upon the the building prior to the arrival of the fire department must be given shrift.

Ask yourself the following:

"What is burning?" Is this a "room and contents" fire, or an actual structure fire in which components integral to the construction of the building are being compromised?"

"How long has the fire been burning?" Was there a delay in notification of the fire department? Is it an advanced fire condition upon arrival of first-due companies?

"What type of structure is the building?" Is the class and means of construction and occupancy immediately evident? If answering "no" to this question, carefully and continually assess the need for and safety of roof operations-especially where any truss roof construction may be suspected.

Once we have committed to the roof, fire conditions must be continually monitored in conjunction with a careful assessment of the progress companies are making toward the extinguishment of the fire.

Before we address the components of the trench cut itself, it is essential that we understand that this is a tactic that is undertaken in ADDITION to vertical ventilation measures, and not in replacement of same.

A solid foundation in vertical ventilation is essential. The vertical ventilation operation should be completed over the fire to alleviate the build-up of the products of combustion for potential victims and the advancing engine and truck companies before any trenching operation is commenced

The trench cut tactic is akin to creating a fire break ahead of the extending fire. This strategy may be employed to combat an unchecked fire found to be extending in the voidspace ahead of companies opening up on the top floor of the structure. The thought process at work here is that by operating carefully ahead of the difficult to reach and extinguish fire, we can cut off the extension of the fire prior to it taking possession of the remainder of the fire building.

Once, the fire is discovered to be extending rapidly in the void space, the decision to make the trench cut may be made. This decision should be communicated to all members on the fireground as coordiantion between the roof operations group and companies operating on the top floor of the fire building is essential. The need for additional companies/alarms should be weighed carefully.

The trench cut should be made as far ahead of the extending fire as possible; twenty (20) feet is a commonly referred to distance. At several points on both sides of the trench site, kerf cuts or inspection holes should be made to monitor the progress of the extending fire. and to assure that the trench is being made in a viable location that the fire has not in fact passed. To review: kerf cuts are made the width or our rotary roof saw blade with one cut into the roofing material, and inspection holes are made in a triangle shape by joining three (3) kerf cuts.

The trench site should be beyond the ventilation opening, and in such a position to allow truck company members easy access to a means of egress from the roof. The means of egress may be an aerial ladder, tower ladder basket, or ground ladder; it is imperative that the escape route be established and understood by all members of the roof operations group should conditions deteriorate to the point where a rapid exit is necessary.

Once we have chosen the site for the trench cut, we will begin the process of cutting the trench itself. The trench must extend from one exterior wall to the next. It is possible to utilize some of the roof features to your advantage to limit the length of the cut by utilizing features of the roof, such as doorways. The cut should be at least three (3) feet in width, although IFSTA does mention four (4) feet as ideal. A good guide to the width of the cut is to use the length of the ubiquitous Halligan tool as a guide. The cut should never exceed the width of an average person's stride, as it may become necessary to step across the cut once it is made. Cut the entire length in parallel fashion from one exterior wall to the other.

Now that we have made the cut, it is important that we deifferentiate between making the trench cut, and opening the trench cut. We will wait to open the trench after assuring that we are in fact still ahead of the advancing fire (check and RECHECK the kerf cuts and/or inspection holes we have made around the trench site), and that companies operating on the top floor of the fire structure are prepared to open up in conjunction with handlines to knock down the fire in the void space. Now that we have assured the viability of the trench cut, and the companies have been notified that we are ready to open the cut, we can now open the trench all the way.

Once we have pulled the trench cut, remember to punch out the ceiling below, and to completely open the trench-especially at the points where the trench joins the exterior walls. Constantly size up evolving conditions on the roof during any vertical ventialtion operation, and notify the incident commander (I/C) of both the progress of the operation and any changes that may impact firground safety.

Be Safe,

Chris

Views: 2687

Replies to This Discussion

Chris, one of the interesting things about a trench cut is how many times it is improperly performed and how often a truck company believes they can achieve this tactic in a timely manner.

In order to properly and correctly perform a trench cut in a timely manner there really needs to be at least four personnel working. Two saws and two hooks working simultaneously. This is really the only way a true trench cut can be achieved in a timely fashion in order to get the benefits of the trench.

The other point is that I have seen truck companies attempt a trench on the typical strip mall tax payer. Generally, these buildings are too wide for the trenching technique. The building needs to provide a chock point in an area that is beneficial to the operation. Like all things in the fire service there needs to be a review of the tactics, strategy and actual hands on. Don't assume you can pull it off when you need to... it must be practice.
Michael:

Great points as usual. You are absolutely correct about the improper performance of this tactic, and that is one of the chief reasons why I wanted to start this discussion.

To your point, this tactic IS personnel intensive and that is why I alluded to the consideration of adequate resources on-scene and the consideration of ordering extra alarms-notwithsatnding the fact that you could be asking the same crew that just finished the vertical ventilation operation to now commence the labor intensive process of cutting the trench, and then possibly pulling the opening across its entire length. We need to do a better job assessing the personnel requirements and resources both on-scene and enroute when weighing the value of commencing this operation.

The time consuming nature of the operation lends itself best to the narrowest portion of the roof; the ideal spot would be the" throat" of the structure where a wing rejoins the larger section of the building (THINK "H" shaped building.) This tactic also works well on the classic narrow taxpayer, rather than the strip mall occupancy you so accurately mentioned, due to the greater depth of today's modern strip malls-not to mention the obvious considerations that have to be taken into account with the commonly encountered light construction of these roof assemblies.

The reminder of the difference between cutting the trench, and actually opening the trench should not be lost either. The decision to open the trench can only be made with coordination of the crews who may be operating in the building, and after we are assured that the fire has not in fact passed the trench location.

Thanks for taking the time to read and respond thoughtfully.

Be Safe,

Chris

RSS

Policy Page

PLEASE NOTE

The login above DOES NOT provide access to Fire Engineering magazine archives. Please go here for our archives.

CONTRIBUTORS NOTE

Our contributors' posts are not vetted by the Fire Engineering technical board, and reflect the views and opinions of the individual authors. Anyone is welcome to participate.

For vetted content, please go to www.fireengineering.com/issues.

We are excited to have you participate in our discussions and interactive forums. Before you begin posting, please take a moment to read our community policy page.  

Be Alert for Spam
We actively monitor the community for spam, however some does slip through. Please use common sense and caution when clicking links. If you suspect you've been hit by spam, e-mail peter.prochilo@clarionevents.com.

FE Podcasts


Check out the most recent episode and schedule of
UPCOMING PODCASTS

Groups

© 2024   Created by fireeng.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service