It would be nice to have some options. All of our Engine Companies are set-up the same way no matter the district. The downtown engine should be set up for commercial operations and the outlying engines for more residential. All of our 2 1/2" nozzles are the playpipe type fog nozzles with the butterfly wings. How are you supposed to start an offensive attack with wings?
Anyway, Standardization is nice, but your engine should be set for your district.
There is no such thing as water damage at a fully involved structure. No fire, no damage. As far as too much water, how much is too much? Put enough water on the fire to extinguish it. What are we trying to protect anyway, the contents or the entire building? My feeling is we need to use the smooth bore nozzle more often. It has been told to me that we need the protection of the fog stream. My feeling is that if the fire is put out, there is no need for preotection........ GPM's on the BTU's
Gregg - Seems a lot of firefighters recieve bad information from rookie school and beyond. The American fire service has many strong myths that are still making the rounds combined with people in power who could change things but they either don't give a damm or don't know fact from fiction.
Ray...great point. We are waiting for our new Squad vehicle that we are putting in my house to replace an engine. Due to height restrictions, we have to mount the ladders on a fold down and out bracket, which means shorter officers side compartments. And since the Squad is going to be more rescue than engine (deep compartments), the tank is narrow, long, and high, putting the hose bed more than 6 1/2 feet off the ground. We carry 800' of 5", 400' static 2 1/2" with 250' strapped ready to go, and 2 1 3/4" pre-connect lines. We will also have 2 crosslays, 1 100' with a fog, and 200' with a fog. All of the lines off the rear will be smooth bore. Needless to say there ain't a whole lot of room for engine related stuff (but the EMS stuff is still there)
It seems like now days many departments have fire apparatus that have a serious identity problem. Engines which want to be trucks and trucks which think they are engines. At FDIC this year I was seriously disapointed in that I did not see a single "battle ready" engine on the showroom floor. Many departments seem to be buying into this more is better attitude. 750 gallon booster tanks on urban engines. Hosebeds which require stepladders to access. I would really like to see a return to the basics in engine design.
The upper hose bed carries 1500 ft X 5 inch (we have several non-residences that require this much hose to reach the nearest hydrant).
The lower hose bed (between the ladder chutes) carries 600 ft X 2&1/2 plus some 3 inch for a portable master stream.
Now guys can pull the shoulder loads without reaching up or stepping up onto the tailboard.
We have one pumper in the shop being retrofitted with this tray (it slides out 100% for repacking) and we hope to retro the other pumper January 1.
I would want the hosebeds lower, especially the rear hosebed. We carry static 1 3/4", but only 4 lengths with a SB nozzle on it. The rest are preconnected with TFTs. I would like to at least have LP nozzles. If it were my choice, I would increase the static bed to 6 lengths. I like the idea of choices between SB and fog, but I can see the training issue that low pressure nozzles can bring (kinks)
See you in Aug!
I would like to change the qualifications or requirements for the operator. Too many people are in a rush to be certified on everything. One problem in the fire service in general is not understanding the pump operators position or engineers position. Trouble shooting the pump has become a lost art with the implementation of pressure governors. Too often people think that the idle button is the answer to every problem without knowing what is happening to cause the problem. This is a very dangerous move for the people on the nozzle that lose pressure in a hostile environment. Another problem is understanding relay pumping. Volume and pressure concepts, pressure losses, hydrant pressures and volumes available need to be understood. You may have a 1250 pump but is the water system where you work going to be deliver that to you? What is it going to take to get that volume? How many gpm's are you going to need to put out the fire you are coming up to? What is your size up as a pump operator? Do you have enough water available if not where are you going to get it from? And what method can it be delivered?
Sorry if it sounds negative but I have been seeing too many people becoming pump operators that are not ready.
My rig is a new Pierce, nice truck, all of the bells and whistles you would want on a pumper. The only thing is that it seems like it was not built for a working company. What I mean by this is that there is no place to store PPE in the cab of the truck while you are away from the station.
I would like to have a lower hosebed, but as a department that responds to rural fires as well as those with municipal water, we have the need for more onboard water. (750 gallons onboard Engine 1, and 750 on Engine 2. Ladder 1 has 500.) I would like to have smooth bore nozzles on our attack lines, but many of the higher ups in the department will never let that happen due to the fact that they "use too much water", or "those are for the big city departments, not ours." It would be nice to get some of the truck tools off the engine, (PPV, Vent saw, Rotary saw, etc.) We are lucky as we do not have any EMS equipment on our Engines. We run our ambulance crew to every fire, but the Engine 2 only responds to MVA incidents. We are also pretty lucky in that thought we don't have set companies, our engineers that respond are veterans who have no problem troubleshooting on the fly. But, sometimes we do have some guys we have to babysit on-scene. But that is somthing we are working on.
"Too much water"?!!!! I feel for you Bro. It is obvious that these guys forgot the first principal of putting out the fire....it is not how much total water you put on the fire, it is the rate you flow, i.e. a 180 GPM SB nozzle flowed for only about 5 to 10 seconds will only flow about 50 gallons, enough for a R+C fire. I see pictures and have witnessed this principal in action many times when a rural FD tries to conserve water while 5 hours later they are mopping up hot spots in the basement, because that is all that is left. Keep up the pressure, and set up some tests. . If you don't have enough water to support an interior attack, at full flows, then the Brothers don't belong in the building in the first place. So...show them with flow meters and inline gauges how mis informed they are. Be safe and don't give up.
We are excited to have you participate in our discussions and interactive forums. Before you begin posting, please take a moment to read our policy page. -- Bobby Halton
Be Alert for Spam
We actively monitor the community for spam, however some does slip through. Please use common sense and caution when clicking links. If you suspect you've been hit by spam, e-mail email@example.com.