Where firefighters come to talk training
Help Translate training from FDIC to my department
While at FDIC I was lucky enough to be part of the HOT class in Truck Company Search and especially the Mask Confidence evolution. My department has always done a training on a maze but never anything like this. I loved it and more importantly learned a ton.. I want to do the same thing for a drill for our volunteers and career staff so I put together a drill proposal and presented it to the training officer. I am part of the training division and assumed I would be putting the drill on in the next few weeks at an aquired structure we have. However, the training officer wants to disect the maze and teach each prop individually in a "safe" environment. I feel that compromises the message of the drill itself. I feel that the reason I will never forget the leasons learned when I went through was because I had to figure out how to properly deal with the situation at hand. I wasn't sounding the floor properly and fell to my chest on the joist - I'll never do that again. I don't think that firefighters will get the same experience if it is peiced together (or rather disected).
Am I crazy or is that "in your face" aspect of this evolution part of the learning experience???
Am I crazy or is that "in your face" aspect of this evolution part of the learning experience???
Replies to This Discussion
-
Permalink Reply by Bob Carpenter on -
Seth,
Both methods have some merit. It has been my experience that making the learning objectives clear and obtainable, with an expectation of success is the most rewarding. Then, after teaching the new technique, demonstrating the steps to succeed then going through "the maze", the participants have the proper action reinforced at the end. When participants are just thrown to the wolves and make errors, the most vivid memory of the exercise is the mistake and the struggle to correct it. It is a way of learning, just not always the most desirable. Keep in mind that different people learn in different ways. The problem with the "just work through the problem" method is that it often results in high levels of frustration on the part of the participant and can really turn off your audience and impact future training endeavours. I think this is what your training officer is trying to avoid.
Remember, the audience and the firehouse on training night may not be as gung ho as we who attend FDIC. That doesn't mean they are less dedicated, just that they didn't sign up for an ass-whipping. :-)
Give it a try this way. You might like the results. I have seen a big change in my department in terms of attitude towards training by simply using this approach.
-
Permalink Reply by Seth Martin on -
I understand that method and the reasoning behind it as well. I am of the opinion that our firefighters have become complacent towards FF survival - it'll never happen to us. I would never allow the student to get to the point of frustration while trying to learn. Like at FDIC my plan was to position instructors to help after a little time of trial and error. I want to train to success, I just feel that a bit of a rude awakening might shock some out of complacency.....maybe I'm wrong.
A Message From Bobby Halton
We are excited to have you participate in our discussions and interactive forums. Before you begin posting, please take a moment to read our policy page HERE.
Badge
Fire Engineering Features
NFPA 1403 Live-Fire Evolutions at Fire Service Training Centers
Live fire training is an essential part of a firefighter's education, but there are significant differences between training at gas-fired versus non-gas-fired structures. Mike Gurr takes a closer look.Fire Engineering University: Online Continuing Education for Firefighters
Fire Engineering University is changing the way fire service professionals approach continuing education. Our goal is to provide you with relevant, topical educational content that is easily accessible. For a full listing of courses with descriptions, credits, and fees, go to www.fireengineeringuniversity.com.New Vehicle Extrication: 2010 Lexus HS250h
The first compact hybrid luxury sedan, this hybrid only model contains several unique features, including numerous air bags. Jason Emery reviews considerations for vehicle rescue operations.© 2009 Created by fireeng
